|
The Bratislava Process
Summary of the First
Six Months and Plan for 2000
INTRODUCTION
The EastWestInstitute (EWI), in cooperation
with the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Slovakia, convened an international
conference titled “The Future of the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia in the
Context of Post War Reconstruction” in Bratislava on July 21-22, 1999.
The conference brought together
representatives of pro-democracy forces from FRY, such as political parties
and NGOs as well as representatives of the international community (European
Union, Council of Europe, OSCE, SECI and others).
One of the key barriers to positive change
noted at the conference was that the groundwork for the FRY's transition to
an open society was not yet prepared. Conference participants from within
and outside the FRY agreed that the removal from office of the country's
current leaders--many of whom have been indicted for war crimes--will not
alone be sufficient for such a transition to take place. Moreover, the
current economic and political isolation of the FRY creates serious barriers
for the people of the FRY to transform their country into a modern, openand
developed society.
The Bratislava Conference also noted the
problems associated with the fragmentation of pro-democracy forces within
Serbia and Montenegro and urged the creation of a “Community for Change
within the FRY" and for a "new international
partnership with the people of the FRY." The Conference further
called for the immediate establishment of a Task Force to assist in
the formation of the Community for Change and to develop a comprehensive
action plan for the future of the FRY. The EastWest Institute has offered to
serve as the Secretariat for the Task Force.
SECTION ONE
Assessment - The Bratislava Process, The First Six Months
The Bratislava Conference marked the
beginingof a new process, known as “The Bratislava Process”. The
Bratislava Process has two aspects. First, the gathering of
pro-democracy forces, political parties, NGO’s, trade unions, student
organizations, and independent media from FRY to form a “Community for
Change”. Secondly, the co-operation of international organizations,
(Council of Europe, OSCE, EU) and Southeastern European regional
international initiatives (SECI, Stability Pact) with the Yugoslav Community
for Change.
Initiating the Bratislava Process marked a
change of perception of Serbia and Montenegro in the eyes of the
international organizations and media. As a result of the eight year long
isolation provoked by Yugoslav President Milosevic and his government, the
existence of pro-democracy forces was not recognized in the West, there was
a widespread belief that there was nobody in Serbia with whom to co-operate.
Bratislava process has shown the opposite. It was clearly demonstrated at
the Bratislava conference that in Yugoslavia there are genuine democrats,
a real people’s movement, including experts and well known individuals,
who desire democratic changes to occur in the country as soon as possible.
It was also demonstrated that in Yugoslavia there is a willingness to
achieve comprehensive structural reforms of the society and the know-how to
accomplish it. This brought about the substantial change in the attitude of
the international organizations and media in their relation towards the
democracy forces in Serbia and Montenegro.
In the past six months there were
achievements in both aspects of the Bratislava Process. Regarding the first
aspect, opposition democratic parties started to build up their joint
strategy for achieving fair and democratic elections and a comprehensive
social reform in October 1999. This effort culminated on January 10, 2000
when all major opposition groups signed two documents announcing the
creation of a broad coalition for free and fair elections. In addition,
co-operation between important civic sector groups (NGO’s, trade unions,
student organizations, independent media) and political parties has
intensified. In short, Community for Change in Yugoslavia has become a
reality.
Regarding the second aspect, international
organizations started with the recognition of Serbian democratic
opposition parties and the reformist government of Montenegro as reliable
partners. The trilateral committee comprised of officials from the EU,
US, and representatives of the democratic forces from FRY was created in
November 1999. Representatives of Community for Change participated as
guests and observers at the OSCE summit in Istanbul in November 1999. The
program “Energy for Democracy” designed by the chief members of the
Community for Change was amply supported by the whole Community and has
since been implemented. Requests by Serbian opposition for easing of the
sanctions that harm the people and do not contribute to change of policy of
the current government have been seriously examined. As a result, EU
suspended on February 14, 2000 the air travelling embargo. This was a
long expected move which has been perceived by the Community for Change in
FRY as a recognition by the international policy makers from the West that
their partnership in the development and stability processes in the region
is viable and committed.
Description of Activities in
the Framework of the Bratislava Process
The framework of the Bratislava Process has
been established through the following activities:
- Task Force on the Future of the Federal
Republic of Yugoslavia
- Open Forum on the Future of the Federal
Republic of Yugoslavia
- Weekly Flash Reports and Analysis
- Policy recommendations
1) Meetings of the Task Force
on the Future of the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia
EWI started preparations for setting up
the Task Force on August 1, 1999, immediately following the Bratislava
conference. The Task Force on the Future of the FRY had the first meeting
in Budapest, on Sept. 8-9, 1999. Second meeting of the Task Force took
place in Strasbourg on Nov. 20-21, 1999. Second meeting was co-sponsored
by EWI and the Council of Europe. The third meeting of the Task Force took
place on January 30-31, 2000, in Belgrade. At the third meeting members of
the Task Force made evaluations of the first six months of the Bratislava
Process and decided upon their work for the future period.
Finally, the fourth meeting of the Task
Force will take place in Podgorica, Montenegro, on Feb. 27-29.
The integral part of this report is the Short
Description of the Task Force and list of members.
There were also four meetings of members
of the Task Force from FRY organized in Belgrade. These meetings were very
important contribution to coalition building processes. Participants find
them to be flexible tool for discussion and developing of the joint
strategies. These meetings became unique place where high ranking
officials of opposition parties meet regularly with important NGO, trade
union and media activists.
2) Open Forum on the Future
of the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia
At the same time when there was a meeting
of the Task Force, sessions of the Open Forum on the Future of the FRY
took place, in which international and Yugoslav experts for political
democratization, civic sector development and the role of media in
democratization processes participated.
First session of the Open Forum was held
in September in Budapest, and was dedicated to the role of media.
Second session of the Forum on the Future
of the FRY was organized under tittle “Staircase to Europe” on
November 20-21, 1999 in Strasbourg. The event was co-sponsored by the Council
of Europe and EWI. It was an important step for the Bratislava
initiative for it was the first time that an European international
organization, the Council of Europe, had opened its doors to
non-governmental pro-democratic partners from Serbia and official and NGO
representatives from Montenegro.
The third session of the Opened Forum:
“Coalition Building for Democratic Change in Serbia – Precondition for
implementation of the Stability Pact in the Region” took place In
Belgrade on Jnauary 30-31 in Belgrade.
Finally, the fourth session of the open
Forum will be dedicated to "Main Aspects of the Relations between
Serbia and Montenegro". It is expected to be important
contribution for solution of the sensitive and controversial issue of
relations between the two republics forming FRY.
Reports and policy recommendations from
the Bratislava conference, Strasbourg and Belgrade sessions of the Open
Forum were broadly distributed to leading decision makers in Europe and
the US, as well as to the general public. These documents became an
important source of information for the decision making processes in FRY
as well as in the international community.
Reports and documents from the Open Forum
Sessions are integral part of this report.
3) Weekly Flash Reports and
Analysis
At the first meeting of the Task Force in
Budapest, on Sept. 8-9, 1999, it was decided that the EastWest Institute
Prague Centre, distribute short weekly reports on events in the FRY to
interested organizations and individuals. The purpose was to create a
regular source of information on events in FRY. Numerous daily news
reports regarding FRY, are available from think tanks specializing in SEE
issues, but there was a lack of short weekly presentations and therefore
the EWI’s reports are unique. Recipients of the weekly reports vary from
key politicians interested in the general events in FRY, but who do not
have time to gather and process the information, to specialists on SEE,
who also find the reports useful, especially for monitoring the
development of political situation in FRY. Since October 1999, 17
issues of these reports have been sent out by e-mail and faxed to many
important decision-makers, diplomats, media outlets and others in the
West. Every week the Institute receives requests for inclusion on the
mailing list.
Encouraged by the high demand for these
Weekly Sheet Reports, EWI leadership has decided to start issuing a Weekly
Analysis. Many recipients of the Weekly Sheet Reports have expressed an
interest in assessments and analysis of main political processes in the
FRY. First such analysis was issued in November, 1999, and assessed the
impact of the international sanctions imposed on FRY and its effect on the
democratization process in FRY. The response to the first issue was
immense. The text was reprinted by the influential weekly
"Vreme" magazine, Belgrade, in November 1999. Opposition leaders
from Serbia used arguments from this text in their negotiations with the
Western leaders in November and December of 1999. The effort of the
Serbian opposition leaders to induce Western leaders to gradually ease the
sanctions succeeded when the EU decided on February 14, 2000 to suspend
the air travelling embargo. This was a symbolic confirmation of the West
to the Serbian opposition.
Regretfully, only three issues of Weekly
Analysis have been printed so far.. Due to overload of activities in
December 1999 through February 2000, this important work was stalled.
However, issuing of the Weekly Analysis on FRY will resume in the last
week of February and will be regularly continued.
4) Policy Recommendations
Policy recommendations agreed upon at the
Bratislava Conference and sessions of the Open Forum have had an impact on
the situation and developments in FRY. Please refer to the following
section.
SECTION TWO
Assessment: Did EWI Make the Difference in FRY ?
By launching the Bratislava Process EWI
made a difference in FRY. Policy recommendations contained in the final
document of the Bratislava conference and sessions of the Open Forum on the
future of FRY had an impact on the political development in FRY and in the
involvement of international organizations regarding FRY.
a) Regarding the situation in
FRY:
Coalition building within FRY was first
mentioned as a pre-condition for democratization at the Bratislava
Conference, July 1999, when political opposition leaders and important
civic sector activists met together with the representatives of
international organizations. As soon as October,1999, the first session of
the Round Table, presided by Democratic Center of Belgrade and its leader
Prof. Micunovic, featuring all major opposition political groups took
place. The Strasbourg session of the Open Forum, as well as meetings
between representatives of the Serbian opposition and the EU and US
representatives from Oct.- Dec. 19999, called for a continuation of the
coalition building initiative, and the inclusion of the civic sector
within it. Coalition-building culminated on Jan. 10, 2000 when 16 major
opposition groups lead by the Serbian Renewal Movement decided to develop
a joint strategy. The Belgrade session of the Open Forum called for
the development of a joint strategy platform between political parties,
NGO's, independent media, trade unions and student organizations.
Following these recommendations, daily consultations are being carried out
in February, 2000 and as a result the joint policy statement is expected
to be issued soon.
b) Regarding the relation of
international community towards pro-democracy forces:
As mentioned above, the Council of
Europe was the pioneer of welcoming pro-democracy forces in Serbia and
Montenegro. This initiative was continued by the US and the EU through
meetings with Serbian democrats, and programs such as "Energy for
Democracy", and as a result these connections have been
institutionalized through the trilateral committee. The selective and
gradual process of lifting the sanctions started with the suspension of
the air travelling embargo, as recommended by EWI and the final documents
of Bratislava and Strasbourg.
SECTION THREE
ACTION PLAN - Bratislava Process in the Year 2000
Activities in the framework of the
Bratislava Process in the year 2000 will vary depending on development of
the situation in FRY. There are three possible scenarios:
a) Free and fair elections
are organized, pro-democracy forces come to power
- Regular elections for the local
authorities and for the federal parliament are due to be organized in
November 2000.
- Pro-democracy forces have the very
serious chance to win these elections, provided they unify their
strategies and efforts through a strong coalition.
- Pressure is to be increased on President
Milosevic. Firstly, his government must allow free and fair elections to
take place as scheduled, with international monitoring. Secondly, in
view of a victorious result for his opponents, the peaceful transfer of
power must ensue. As Ambassador Istvan Gyarmati, senior member of EWI
and an expert in SEE issues expressed at a recent meeting of EWI, ”the
West has to convince President Milosevic that the less painful thing for
him to undergo is to allow the transfer of power to democratically
elected new representatives.”
b) Status quo scenario
- Government of President Milosevic will
remain in power, and postpone elections for a long period of time.
Economic situation will continue to gradually deteriorate in the year
2000, but without major humanitarian crisis. Oppression against
opposition parties and free media will continue at the present path,
without having major acute crisis, but with overall situation gradually
deteriorating.
c) Increase of oppression -
Civil unrest with possible civil war as a consequence
- The present regime will increase
oppression. Political and civic sector leaders will be arrested, with
the possibility of disappearances under circumstances not clarified by
police and the judiciary. This might provoke massive protests of the
opposition groups and subsequent massive civil unrest. If the regime
decided to oppress the unrest , a civil war might occur. Total collapse
of the economy and a humanitarian catastrophe are likely to occur under
such conditions.
The activities in the framework of the
Bratislava process will depend on which scenario takes place.
However, if we presume that the most
positive scenario will take place, there are two phases in which EWI will be
active. In the first phase, before the elections, EWI will be
working in the following:
1) Meetings of the Task Force
- Open Forum on the Future of FRY
Meetings and sessions of the Open Forum
will be continued this year.
In the Year 2000 six such meetings should
take place. The first was organized in January 2000, in Belgrade. The
second will take place in Podgorica, on February 27-29, 2000
Additional four meetings should be
organized in April, June, September and November 2000, with locations and
topics to be determined by the members of the Task Force in accordance
with the development of the situation in FRY.
Reports from the meetings, containing
analysis and policy recommendations will continue to be an important
contribution in policy-making processes in FRY as well as among the
international organizations.
2) Weekly Sheet Reports and
Weekly Analysis
EWI will continue to issue regular
reports and analysis regarding developments in FRY.
3) Monthly Economic Bulletin
Together with G-17, a prominent think
tank of independent economists, EWI began publishing in February 2000 a
monthly economic bulletin. The purpose to provide relevant reliable
information in the economic field of FRY. Being excluded from the World
Bank’s monitoring system, FRY did not provide basic information
regarding its economy. EWI and G-17 launched a monthly economic bulletin
in an effort to fulfill this gap, and with the ambition to provide basic
data needed for the future participation of FRY in the SEE Stability Pact
and the implementation of Stability Pact in FRY in the near future.
4) Meetings of the Yugoslav
Sector of the Task Force
There will be at least one such meeting
every month. This will continue to be an important venue for the
coalition-building processes, developing with the unified strategies of
all the members of the Community for Change.
5) Civic Diplomacy Activities
President Milosevic and his government
should be more isolated in the international scene. His propaganda is
misleading and misrepresenting facts. Community for Change should be
helped to provide the necessary information on the damaging effects of
Milosevic’s FRY policies and its impact on SEE as a whole, and, the
potential benefits of supporting Community for Change. Co-operation
between Community for Change, the West and CEE, Asian and Pacific regional
countries and international organizations needs to be institutionalized.
It is important for showing the Yugoslav people that President Milosevic
is not welcomed by any stable nation or leader, and, that members of the
Community for Change are seen as the true representatives of the Yugoslav
people.
6) Synergies with other EWI
programs and SEE regional activities
EWI’s programs on Transfrontier
Cooperation (TFC), security in the SEE and the Parliamentarian Network (MPN)
will be coordinated with the activities of the Bratislava process. Ways how
these programs should be implemented in FRY will be discussed at regular
Task Force meetings. The same applies for all other SEE regional activities.
7) Publications, Internet site,
Internet Discussion Group
EWI will make an effort to issue
publications on the Bratislava Process more efficiently. All publications
will be placed and easily accessible through EWI’s internet site (www.iews.org).
Through “Balkan Network” a regional internet site maintained by the
Association for Sustainable Development of Belgrade, a discussion group
will be formed for the members of the Task Force and other interested
members of the public.
8) Donors conferences
Conferences between representatives of
donors and Community for Change will be co-organized by EWI and the
Belgrade Fund for an Open Society. Two conferences will be organized this
year in Prague, EWI Centre. At these meetings donors will discuss the
strategy for supporting Community for Change.
In the second phase, after the electoral
process, EWI will consider
opening a EWI Regional Centre in Belgrade, for South Eastern Europe. With
its immense experience in transition countries of Central and Eastern
Europe, the Institute will participate in developing programs on
economic reconstruction and development, democratization and legislation
and rule of law reforms in co-operation with Serbian and Montenegrin
specialists in respective fields.
Prepared by:
Aleksandar Lojpur,
Co-ordinator of the Task Force on the Future of the Federal Republic of
Yugoslavia,
February 25, 2000
Contact:
Aleksandar Lojpur
EastWest Institute
Rašinovo Nabřeži 78
120 00 Prague 2,
Czech Republic
Phone: +420 2 21984216
Fax: +420 2 294 380
e-mail: alojpur@iews.cz
|